2025
| January | The Way We Live Now | Anthony Trollope |
| February | North Woods | Daniel Mason |
| March | The Ride of Her Life | Elizabeth Letts |
| April | Horse | Geraldine Brooks |
| May | The Promise | Damon Galgut |
| June | Loneliness and Company | Charlee Dyroff |
| July | The Wedding People | Alison Espach |
| August | Fun Home | Alison Bechdel |
2024
| January | Death Comes for the Archbishop | Willa Cather |
| February | Search: A Novel | Michelle Huneven |
| March | Sexing the Cherry | Jeanette Winterson |
| April | The Lemon Tree: An Arab, a Jew, and the Heart of the Middle East | Sandy Tolan |
| May | The Personal Librarian | Marie Benedict and Victoria Christopher Murray |
| June/July | Lessons in Chemistry | Bonnie Garmus |
| August | Small Things Like These | Claire Keegan |
| September | Their Eyes Were Watching God | Zora Neale Hurston |
| October | Trail of the Lost | Andrea Lankford |
2023
| January | West with Giraffes | Lynda Rutledge |
| February | The Color of Water | James McBride |
| March | Her Honor | LaDoris Hazzard Cordell |
| April | There, There | Tommy Orange |
| May | Hamnet | Maggie O’Farrell |
| June | The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie: A Flavia de Luce Mystery | Alan Bradley |
| July / August | The Lincoln Highway | Amor Towles |
| September | Hons and Rebels | Jessica Mitford |
| October | The Thursday Murder Club | Richard Osman |
2022
| January | Two Years Before the Mast | Richard Henry Dana |
| February | A Dream Called Home | Reyna Grande |
| March | Changes, Challenges, Choices…and a lot of luck | Ursula Gobets |
| April | All Quiet on the Western Front | Erich Maria Remarque |
| May | Frankenstein | Mary Shelley |
| June | My Beloved World | Sonia Sotomayor |
| July | Deacon King Kong | James McBride |
| August | Nomadland | Jessica Bruder |
| September | The Distance Between Us | Reyna Grande |
| October | Mary Coin | Marisa Silver |
2021
| January | My Ántonia | Willa Cather |
| February | Remarkable Creatures | Tracy Chevalier |
| March | News of the World | Paulette Jiles |
| April | Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy | John le Carre |
| May | Rising Out of Hatred: The Awakening of a Former White Nationalist | Eli Saslow |
| June | The Dutch House | Ann Patchett |
| July | The Night Watchman | Louise Erdrich |
| August | This Is How It Begins: A Novel | Joan Dempsey |
| September | True at First Light | Ernest Hemingway |
| October | No-No Boy | John Okada |
2020
| January | Where the Crawdads Sing | Delia Owens |
| February | The Tenth Muse: A Novel | Cathryn Chung |
| March | Rules of Civility | Amor Towles |
| April | Just Mercy | Bryan Stevenson |
| May | Unsheltered | Barbara Kingsolver |
| June | Excellent Women | Barbara Pym |
| July / August | The Overstory | Richard Powers |
| September | A Mighty Long Way | Carlotta Walls Lanier
& Lisa Frazier Page |
| October | A Woman of No Importance | Sonia Purnell |
2019
| January | The Clan of the Cave Bear | Jean M. Auel |
| February | The Reluctant Fundamentalist | Mohsin Hamid |
| March | The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry | Gabrielle Zevin |
| April | Becoming | Michelle Obama |
| May | The Strange Career of Jim Crow | C. Vann Woodward |
| June | Why Be Happy When You Can Be Normal? | Jeanette Winterson |
| July | Women Rowing North | Mary Pipher |
| August | Women in Love | D.H. Lawrence |
| September | In the Midst of Winter | Isabel Allende |
| October | Educated: A Novel | Tara Westover |
